Graded Games
The Graded Games Report

Super Mario Bros. NES Fetches $18,500 Amid Market Shift

This week, the graded video game market saw notable shifts, with Super Mario Bros. leading the charge at $18,500. Overall, the average sale dipped slightly, but several standout titles captured collectors' attention.

635 Sales tracked ▲ 4%
$600 Avg price ▼ 5%
$250 Median price ▼ 15%

434 of 635 sales had confirmed prices · hottest grader PSA · most active console PS2

Market Summary

Sales tracked this week increased to 635, with 434 games priced, showing a rise in activity despite a decrease in median sale price from $295 to $250. The PS2 and Game Boy consoles continue to showcase strong demand, particularly for sealed titles.

Main Points
  • Super Mario Bros. for NES leads with a sale of $18,500.
  • Kingdom Hearts II sold for $895, nearly double its comp price.
  • Average sales this week dipped to $600, reflecting shifting market dynamics.
🔥 Running hot

Consoles PS2 · Game Boy · NES

Grades WATA 9.4 · PSA

Titles Super Mario Bros. · Pokémon Blue · Pokémon Silver Version

💎 Looks undervalued
  • Grand Theft Auto San Andreas (PS2): Sold for $102, just 16% of its comparable value of $650.
  • Call of Duty Modern Warfare 2 Steelbook (Xbox 360): Sold for $580, only 38% of its market comparison of $1,525.
  • Gears of War Judgement (Xbox 360): At $98, it's selling at 60% of its comp price of $162.
Top Sales

The highlight of the week was the sale of Super Mario Bros. for NES, which sold for $18,500, showcasing the enduring appeal of this classic title.

Beat Its Comp · condition + variant matched

Kingdom Hearts II on PS2 fetched $895, representing a notable premium of 1.9 times its comparable sales price of $470, indicating strong collector interest.

Kingdom Hearts II 2 Sony PlayStation 2 PS2 Sealed New Sealed
PS2 · PSA 9.6 A+ · sold $895 vs $470 typical sealed comp (n=2)
1.9×
Deals · sold under comp

Notable deals were observed with several loose and graded games selling well below their market comps, suggesting potential opportunities for savvy collectors.

Grand Theft Auto San Andreas (Sony PlayStation 2 PS2) Loose
PS2 · WATA 9.6 A++ · sold $103 vs $650 comp (n=3)
−84%
Grand Theft Auto Vice City GTA PS2 Graded Loose
PS2 · WATA 9.8 A++ · sold $175 vs $812 comp (n=2)
−78%
Grand Theft Auto III 3 Sony PlayStation 2 PS2 Sealed New Double Pack Sealed
PS2 · PSA 9.8 A++ · sold $111 vs $483 comp (n=8)
−77%
Call of Duty Modern Warfare 2 Steelbook Microsoft Xbox 360 Sealed Sealed
Xbox 360 · PSA 9.6 A++ · sold $580 vs $1,525 comp (n=3)
−62%
Gears of War Judgement Microsoft Xbox 360 Sealed New Sealed
Xbox 360 · PSA 9.8 A++ · sold $98 vs $162 comp (n=2)
−40%
PSA 9.8 A++ Grand Theft Auto III 3 Sony PlayStation 2 PS2 Trilogy Seal Sealed
PS2 · PSA 9.8 A++ · sold $336 vs $483 comp (n=8)
−30%

Sales that closed well below their like-for-like comp this period: potential buys, or signs of softening demand.

Condition & Grade

Sealed games continue to dominate the market with a median sale price of $276, while loose games follow at $203, indicating varied collector preferences.

Sealed
$276
median · 391 sales · $728 avg
9.8$228 (82)
9.6$268 (40)
Ungraded$250 (37)
9.2$338 (19)
CIB
$300
median · 60 sales · $423 avg
Ungraded$200 (9)
7.5$436 (7)
8.5$599 (4)
8.0$670 (3)
Loose
$203
median · 184 sales · $384 avg
9.8$118 (45)
Ungraded$324 (30)
9.6$177 (22)
9.4$110 (5)
Notable-Title Grade Guide

Graded titles, particularly those rated by WATA and PSA, are maintaining their value, with top sales reflecting the importance of condition in pricing.

Cardboard-box eraNES · SNES · N64 · GB
A++A+A
9.8 $1,076 (13)
$155–$15,177
$2,125 (8)
$499–$4,552
$3,000 (1)
9.6 $1,200 (7)
$450–$18,999
$633 (12)
$200–$7,522
$4,125 (2)
$1,500–$6,750
9.4 $2,825 (6)
$400–$5,851
$1,814 (23)
$225–$30,000
$775 (3)
$699–$3,599
9.2 $5,000 (1) $540 (16)
$200–$6,000
$898 (3)
$517–$6,300
9.0 $2,000 (1) $3,040 (11)
$255–$12,000
$327 (3)
$230–$400
8.5 $250 (1) $1,537 (6)
$820–$5,750
$1,370 (10)
$245–$5,000
DVD / plastic-case eraPS1–5 · Xbox · GameCube
A++A+A
9.8 $160 (102)
$33–$7,500
$440 (92)
$36–$20,000
$725 (14)
$180–$2,000
9.6 $314 (19)
$113–$2,039
$300 (81)
$33–$5,999
$355 (27)
$46–$3,000
9.4 $375 (1) $225 (33)
$30–$1,100
$296 (17)
$41–$6,995
9.2 $195 (2)
$80–$310
$128 (8)
$22–$1,600
$200 (9)
$56–$1,224
9.0 · $158 (3)
$48–$452
$56 (3)
$44–$450
8.5 · $115 (2)
$110–$120
$218 (3)
$99–$600

Median & range by grade × sub-grade for collector franchises (last 90 days). (n) = sample size; dimmed = thin data. Cardboard-box games command a premium over disc-era at the same grade.

Notable Median by Console × Grade
Console9.89.69.49.29.08.5
PS2 $340 (36)$299 (27)$264 (18)$164 (6)·$110 (1)
GameCube $700 (16)$510 (31)$439 (12)$690 (5)·$600 (1)
Switch $109 (52)$411 (4)$55 (4)···
N64 $599 (5)$450 (7)$2,000 (12)$1,147 (12)$4,992 (5)$965 (12)
Game Boy Advance $2,250 (11)$713 (12)$775 (9)$250 (4)$1,500 (5)$1,227 (6)
Wii $358 (16)$275 (16)$174 (4)$136 (3)$247 (2)$99 (1)
Xbox 360 $401 (12)$234 (15)$120 (6)$201 (6)·$67 (1)
Nintendo DS $770 (19)$425 (8)$356 (6)$148 (2)··
PS1 $636 (21)$525 (8)$218 (3)·$300 (1)$527 (2)
NES ·$2,725 (2)$3,599 (9)$1,704 (7)$1,038 (8)$287 (8)
PS3 $191 (20)$180 (9)$266 (2)$110 (1)··
Nintendo 3DS $180 (20)$107 (6)$116 (2)$250 (1)$132 (1)·
Game Boy $7,500 (1)$1,500 (3)$2,100 (7)$3,265 (2)$4,500 (4)$495 (8)
SNES $1,077 (2)$589 (2)$2,000 (4)$232 (6)$1,100 (4)$716 (7)

Median notable-title sale by console across grades 9.8–8.5 (last 90 days). A 9.8 is not one market. Disc-era grails top the list while high-population modern games sit far lower.

Sealed vs CIB by Packaging
SealedCIBLoose
Cardboard-box $600 (1190)$450 (650)$390 (432)
DVD / case $250 (2676)$300 (129)$250 (1438)
Console Breakdown · Sealed vs CIB

The PS2 remains a strong contender this week, but the Game Boy and NES also showcased impressive sales, highlighting diverse collector interests.

ConsoleSalesMedianSealedCIB
PS2 98 $225 $200 (45) $360 (1)
Xbox 360 62 $112 $112 (30) $81 (1)
N64 54 $540 $680 (33) $349 (7)
Switch 47 $102 $185 (10) ·
PS1 46 $325 $400 (19) $300 (3)
NES 43 $311 $338 (11) $203 (13)
PS3 36 $264 $260 (16) ·
Nintendo 3DS 28 $288 $200 (9) $147 (1)
PS4 25 $85 $92 (12) ·
Xbox 23 $300 $275 (10) ·
SNES 22 $355 $414 (9) $360 (3)
Game Boy 21 $674 $300 (7) $919 (2)

This period's volume and median by condition, per console.